2.03.2006

Where's the Islam?

I made a trip to the downtown library which is the main branch, with what I would presume a large collection. I searched for Lahore Girls, the Kite Runner and Muhammad: His Life Based on the Earliest Sources, by Martin Lings. The library was out of the first two books. Apparently they must only carry one copy, because this was my third attempt to check out these books. I made a request to put these books on hold and asked the librarian about the Lings’ book. She informed me that they don’t carry it and we checked the shelves only to find a handful of books on the prophet. She said, “Here take one of these.” I informed her that I didn’t want one of those; I wanted the Lings’ book, because it is deemed to be one of the most unbiased and factually accurate biographies (according to my family, friends and many fellow bloggers). She says, “What do you need it for class?” What? As if my only interest for a specific book about the prophet could be as a result of a mandate. Arghhh.

So, I decided to stop by my local Border’s Bookstore. The bookstore is located in a fairly affluent area of town which is noted for its multi-cultural and diverse inhabitants. I was able to locate the religion section because of its large size. The section spanned an entire wall and is undoubtedly the largest subject of the bookstore. Several large placards were lined along the wall indicating religious preference with fairly large bookcases containing various books under each. They were as follows: “New Age” “Christianity”, “Christian Fiction”, “Christian Influence”, “Judaic”, and “Eastern Religions”. I re-read them, looking for “Islam”. Scan, scan, re-scan, nope, not listed. Stunned, this peaked my curiosity.

Perhaps, Islam is in the Eastern Religions section, I thought? Nope. Mind you, there are several bookcases devoted to Christian and one entirely for Judaic books. Under Eastern Religions, there are several bookshelves dedicated to Taoism, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc. I began to get more upset as I searched for “Islam”.

I must have looked like a madwoman as I scanned the shelves, shuffling back and forth amongst the peaceful people sitting in their chairs, absorbing their new treasures. I thought to myself, “How could the fastest growing religion with millions of followers, one of the BIG three, not have a section at this corporate monster?” Surely, it has to be here, they can’t be that blatantly racist, there are thousands of Muslims who live here.

Finally, I located eleven, count ‘em ELEVEN books, two of which were anti-Islam, which took up one half of a bookshelf under the “Christianity” heading. Furthermore, not one copy of the Koran could be found.

I am stunned and insulted. I debated about approaching management about this concern of mine. But, I decided to first go home and find out, via my trusty internet, whether or not there are other people who have noticed this trend in their local Borders. I found one man out of Toledo, Ohio who voiced the same concern. He tried, unsuccessfully, to get his local Muslim group, Toledo Muslims, to join him in signing off a letter to the Border’s headquarters. Although, he did not get any fellow brothers and sisters to give their john hancock, he was successfully in his solo venture. His local Border’s now has a proper heading of “Islam” in their religion section and they now carry the Koran.

From today’s experience, I gather that this man’s fight has not influenced the corporate strategy. I plan to approach management with this by presenting a letter. I would like to know whether or not this is a problem of local or national scope. Please share with me your findings, if you are a Borders shopper. I'm most certain that the stock must vary by area demand, so I am curious about your experiences. Join me and giving Islam the literary space it deserves.

11 Comments:

At 8:45 PM, Blogger pixie said...

That is horrible. I don't ever go into Borders because I am a loyal Barnes and Noble shopper but I will have to go and check it out now.

 
At 4:03 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lings is a good, but two other that you might want to read are:

1) Life of Muhammad : A Translation of Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah. by Alfred Guillaume. Some excerpts can be found at the following address http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/muhammadi-sira.html

2)Michael Cook, Muhammad (Past Masters).

Of the two the first is the earliest known biography of the prophet translated from original arabic and the second is written by a specialist in Islamic history for non specialists. So it is very readable and very good.

We don't even have a Borders in College Station but my experience is that it is difficult to find any thing decent at Barnes and Noble and Bordears. The best way to buy cheap and good books is through www.bookfinder.com it will tell you who carries a book almost anywhere in the world and for how much. The other good thing is to visit book stores around the major university in your area I guess it would be Ohio State.

 
At 7:38 PM, Blogger Aisha said...

Baji what an odd experience because I used to work at Borders and that infuriated me as well. They then insisted that they had one and that it must have fell off. Your experience tells me this isint true. I'm surprised there was such a limited selection though b/c Islam is a hot topic since 9/11 and the bookstores around here do carry a lot of Islamb ooks.

I'll have to cehck that book on the life of the prophet out. I've eben looking for an unbiase book as well. Thanks for the recommendatiion.

 
At 11:00 AM, Blogger Huda said...

I go to several Borders (for Aisha, since we live in the same town -- the Buckhead one and the Perimeter one, mostly, but also sometimes the Ponce one and the Vinings one), and while they don't all have an "Islam" header (although I'm fairly certain the Buckhead and Vinings ones do), I've never had an issue with the amount of Islamic books they have on the shelf. They usually have at least two shelves of books, so I'm surprised that yours isn't as well-stocked. Still, can't hurt to shoot off a letter to your Borders store manager, with a copy going to corporate management.

And on another note, have you read Karen Armstrong's Muhammad? It's very good, and Armstrong tends to be objective.

 
At 9:11 PM, Blogger Baji said...

Pixie, thanks for visiting.

Hassan and Huda, thanks for visiting. I will definitely check out your suggestions, too.

 
At 5:59 AM, Blogger luckyfatima said...

i've noticed a generally dreary selection of quality books about Islam at both Barnes and Borders. Their stuff is usually the typical non-Muslim Orientalist version of Islam stuff. I prefer to order from amazon based on friends' recommendations.

 
At 12:24 PM, Blogger mystic-soul said...

I will not worry.

Bias from one bookstore should not bother us. Knowledge is a bright light - no one can shut it off. Also internet has opened all doors to access to any knowledge you want. Let them live in their own world. Its not worth even a single letter to such low mentality.

Last night, I heard a report on BBC that a real well know library with a lot of historical books and only place to have all known books on kashmir history "Khurshid memorial library" get destroyed in earthquake. What a waste.

Personally, I prefer Barnes and nobles though.

 
At 11:58 AM, Blogger Aisha said...

unrelated tangent. Did you end up deciding on pakistan?

 
At 7:05 PM, Blogger Baji said...

Aisha, I have decided to keep up the job search for the next two weeks. If nothing comes about, I will prob. work temp. services for a month and then spend a few weeks in Pakistan. Thanks for asking!

 
At 7:06 PM, Blogger Baji said...

Mystic, that is so sad.

 
At 10:47 PM, Blogger Trailady said...

I had no trouble finding books on Islam at our local Borders Bookstore. Perhaps it was just the one you were at??

 

Post a Comment

<< Home